SMS: Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies

Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies

I’ve always had a penchant for peanut butter, especially when featured as a foil ingredient in one of many perfect pairings: peanut butter and jelly, peanut butter and banana, and of course, the ultimate combination, peanut butter and chocolate. The first candies consumed from my Halloween loot were usually Reese’s peanut butter cups, and as a Brownie, Thin Mints and Samoas didn’t hold a candle to my favorite girl scout classic, Tagalongs, or peanut butter patties. Despite my preference for peanut butter, I must admit it is an under-utilized item in my kitchen. But with this week’s SMS pick, Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies, I got to grab my jumbo jar of creamy Skippy and mix up a simple yet scrumptious batch of goodies, filling my home with a warm, nutty, comforting aroma that transporting me back to my childhood.

PB Cookies 1

In these timeless treats, the peanut butter is front and center without any other flavors competing for attention. Charming and unpretentious, they are easy to whip up on a whim, with all the ingredients likely to be in your pantry. A few months ago when my Aunt Maggie and I got together for a baking date, we fell back on PB cookies after eliminating some flashier desserts that required items we didn’t have on hand. We actually used a similar recipe to the variation in the Sweet Melissa Baking Book, and though the differences were subtle, I think I preferred this latest version. Stephanie of Ice Cream Before Dinner mentioned she selected this SMS recipe because it produced a simple and not so fancy cookie that would ultimately be an enjoyable crowd-pleaser. With soft, tender centers, crispy edges, a delicate texture, and predominant peanutty flavor, they definitely live up to their name and expectations.

PB Cookies 2

Peanut butter cookies are actually a part of American culinary history. George Washington Carver, an African-American agriculturalist who promoted the peanut as a replacement for the cotton crop, compiled 105 peanut recipes from various cookbooks, agricultural bulletins and other sources. In his 1916 Research Bulletin called “How to Grow the Peanut and 105 Ways of Preparing it for Human Consumption,” he included three recipes for peanut cookies calling for crushed/chopped peanuts as an ingredient. Later, in the early 1920s, peanut butter was listed as a primary ingredient in the cookies.

PB Cookies 3

And did you ever wonder the origin of the traditional criss-cross pattern? Leave it to Pillsbury to establish this characteristic look- the Peanut Butter Balls recipe in the 1923 edition of Pillsbury’s Balanced Recipes contains the first known written instance of instructing the baker to press the cookies with the tines of a fork. Because of the dough’s density, it will not cook evenly without being pressed, and a fork is definitely a convenient tool in every kitchen to complete this job. The cross-hatched marking immediately identifies the peanut butter cookie, distinguishing it from any other variety, and adding to its delightfully rustic appearance.


These cookies were fun and fast to bake, and would be a great project to do with kids. Since this recipe edges out others I’ve made in the past, I think it will be a permanent addition to my cookie-baking repertoire. Thank you to Stephanie of Ice Cream Before Dinner for her delicious down-home selection, and if you feel like filling your cookie jar with a batch of your own, head on over to her adorable site for the recipe. And you can see all the other SMS baker’s treats by checking out our blogroll, now featuring a few new members (myself included)!

Joy Heart 2


22 responses

  1. What a great post! So interesting to hear the history. Your photos are fantastic – they make me want to get off my couch and go grab another couple of these cookies but I’m going to try exercise some restraint 🙂

  2. I’m glad you liked these cookies. While I was at it, I decided to do a side-by-side comparison of 2 PB cookie recipes. Hubby liked the SMS cookie, although he preferred the “other” cookie :o)

    We’ll see what my coworkers think of these cookies tomorrow. I need all the input I can get since I can’t try them for myself (allergies).

    Hope you have a nice week!

  3. Beautiful photos, they look delicious! When I was making the cookies, my boyfriend asked why peanut butter cookies are the only ones that are pressed with a fork and I meant to look it up, so I’m happy you shared the history.

  4. What a lovely post! And I feel like I know so much more about peanut butter now! I have to agree- a great recipe for kids. My three year old loved making the cross hatches.

  5. Hi Joy!! Your cookies look AMAZING!! I aspire to have such beautiful cookies! I’m going out to buy FRESH ingredients for the Snickerdoodles this weekend. Cross your fingers for me. The last batch I attempted was a DISASTER! Disaster, I say! All my cookies tend to end up really thin and flat. Wonder why that is.

    Anywho, I got the snickerdoodle recipe from Spike. I just need the TWD one, if you would please: Brownie Buttons.


  6. Your cookies look delicious, Joy! I really liked these, too, and I’m sure I’ll be making them again!

    Interesting about the cross-hatch, I always wondered about that…

  7. Joy – your cookies look beautiful!! And I love how much care & knowledge you put into these posts – you’re better than wikipedia… Bake-a-pedia!

    I also want to send a big, sugary THANK YOU hug for your help with the SMS avatar!! plus some short ‘n sweet ones: thank you, thank you, thank you!
    I finally feel like a real blogger now, haha..

    Can’t wait to bake with you again on Sunday – bring on the lovely doodles 🙂

  8. Joy!!!

    1) LOVE YOUR BLOG!!! Concept, photos, icon’s not to mention photolabels and your logo! Brava mistress of the mixmaster.

    2) Next time you are cooking with my mum let me know I wanna bake too!

    3) Scott wants you to know if you decide to have a side by side comparison of pb cookies ever again- he would like to volunteer as your “professional taste tester.” As these cookies are his all time favs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s